These separators are in wide use on general aviation piston powered planes. I was glad to see you are not discharging the collected oil to the intake because of the turbo problems that would have resulted. However, by pulling a vacuum on the breather are you not pulling more vapor than would otherwise be seen on the crankcase breather?
The crankcase gets positive pressure from ring wear, which in turn pushes more and more air (the product of combustion so it is really not air) into the crankcase. That air is dirty and gets dirtier as the engine wears and it increases in volume as the engine wears. It has lots of carbon particulates so in this case that dirty oil is being returned. Personally I would rather just see a gravity trap that would be drained at every oil change cycle.
On planes, which consume a lot of oil, most of it out the breather, trapping that and returning it to the crankcase doesn't make any more sense to me, but it has been an accepted practice so there will be no changing it now.
I doubt if it is a money issue as much as the problem is so insignificant as to be not worth the engineering time. Right now I suspect all engineers working for all engine manufacturers are working hard to put exhaust into the environment that is cleaner than the air in that environment.


Reply With Quote