PDA

View Full Version : Reflections on 4 Years of Prevost Owner$hip



phorner
08-04-2011, 04:32 PM
September 5, 2011 will mark the 4 year anniversary of the purchase of our 2000 Liberty Lady Classic. What a day that was! We had been “shopping” off and on for just about a year and the day we made our purchase will always be remembered as one of the happiest and proudest days of my life.

It was hard to believe that we owned a Prevost bus, and a Liberty Coach at that! Although we had looked at others, Liberty Coach was at the top of our list then and it remains today, in our opinion, the best of the best.

Now, you may hear Jon say “you don't know what you don't know” from time to time. Truer advice was never given. It's not meant to be dismissive of your experience or intellect. It is simply a statement of fact. As a newbie Prevost owner, and only a newcomer to POG, I epitomized the clueless when it came to being prepared to purchase a Prevost bus. If I had truly understood then what I have come to learn over the past 4 years, I would have been a much different buyer. I would have asked better, tougher questions of the seller. I would have asked for documentation, in writing. I would have inspected the bus much more thoroughly through much better eyes. Take Jon's advice to heart.

For those POG members that are reluctant to participate in the forum, perhaps still shopping for that first Prevost, I strongly encourage you to search and read the posts and try to absorb as much of the collective knowledge and experience as you can BEFORE you part with your hard earned cash. Better yet, don't hesitate to jump in and ask questions. It will be the best investment in time and effort you can make.

To back up a bit, Janice and I retired in 2002 and had at that time been “motorhoming” for 4 years, starting out with a 32' gas powered Allegro Bus. When we retired, we sold the house, the Harleys, the Corvette, the '70 Dodge Challenger R/T, and all the household “stuff” and went to live full time in our 40' Safari motorhome, expecting to winter on our lot in Port Saint Lucie, Florida and travel during the summer. It would be an “endless vacation.”

As time went by we replaced the Safari with a 42' Beaver motorhome and eventually we decided that if we wanted a coach that would truly hold up to extended travel and full time living, we would need a real bus. We also wanted to be “slide free”. It looked like the 1997 – 2000 Prevost XLV conversions would be perfect for us. A good old “classic bus” might be in our price range and be perfect for us.

And perfect it was. We could not have been more pleased with our Liberty. This bus has a good heart. This bus has “soul”. This bus has been the conduit to many wonderful trips. We have traveled from Florida to Maine, New Jersey to California and most places in between. We have become spoiled by never having to pack for a trip. Every night is in our own bed. “Home” never changes.... only the scenery. We have met and enjoyed the company of scores of wonderful people. This bus is “us”.

Now, before we purchased our Liberty, I asked another bus owner “if I can manage to put together enough money to actually buy a bus, how expensive is the maintenance?” After a moment of thought, he said “not bad, really... probably not significantly more than you're spending now on your Beaver.”

I bring this up for the education of new POGers and those about to purchase their first bus as it underscores the need to be as fully educated as possible while making the purchase decision. First of all, “significant” is subjective and means different things to different people. As an example, while $1,000 might be significant to some, it may go unnoticed by others. Hence the advice to know what you're looking for, what questions to ask and what to expect BEFORE you make your purchase. Maintaining a bus, or bringing one up to snuff, can be expensive. To a certain degree, it can depend on your comfort level of ownership. I primarily prioritize our maintenance into four general categories: Safety, Reliability, Comfort/convenience, and Cosmetics, in that order.

Over the past 4 years, we have spent $47,173.03 in maintenance. That's nearly $1,000 each and every month since ownership.... and I still have some work yet to do this year.

We have driven our Liberty bus 21,337 miles thus far. That means our bus maintenance has cost us about $2.21 for every mile. This does not include fuel which averages right around 50 cents a mile for us. Fuel cost pales in comparison to any other aspect of bus ownership.

And, it doesn't include the big one; depreciation.

Now, these figures need to be be kept in the proper perspective as some of the work accomplished during this four year period won't need to be done again in a while (batteries, tires, brake chambers, etc.), some not for quite some time (air springs, Norgren valves, aux compressor, engine bellows, etc.) and some perhaps never (upper and lower A arms, upholstery) so a longer term would likely yield much different annualized costs of maintenance.

This is being posted in an effort to open the eyes of would-be or new Prevost bus owners. If you don't take the time and make the effort to become knowledgeable, you can quickly spend a lot of money.

All that being said, it has been an incredible, wonderful experience. I am sure glad we had an opportunity to realize this dream. The parts of this wonderful country that we have been fortunate enough to travel through and explore have been awesome. The friendships and relationships forged through POG and our bus travels have been incredibly rewarding.

But, after more than 9 years of full-timing in a motorcoach, it is time for us to start thinking about a more permanent home. We will be hanging up the keys as both our lot in Saint Lucie West and our beloved Liberty Coach will shortly be up for sale. In todays market, we expect it to take some time, so we're not disappearing anytime soon.

Speaking only for myself, Prevost ownership is/was everything I had dreamed of.

rahangman
08-04-2011, 05:01 PM
Ditto on many, many of your thoughts.

truk4u
08-04-2011, 06:04 PM
Nicely done Paul, but from a selfish standpoint, I hope it takes awhile for your sale. You and Janice have been an inspiration to folks wanting to full time and it will be a sad day for POG when you hang up your keys.

On the other hand, Woo Hoo, we'll have a place to mooch from wherever you land and sounds like exciting times are ahead with a home that doesn't have wheels. Just think, Ms Ivy can then bounce off the walls of many rooms and climb the curtains.:p

Keep us posted and try to make Austin before kicking the Liberty to the curb.

aggies09
08-04-2011, 07:10 PM
Although I was greener than Paul in experience, I have to echo many of his sentiments relating to coach ownership. I had many of the same requirements Paul did and in hindsight our '97 Liberty n/s was perfect for us as well. When it comes to maintenance of theses coaches you cannot be faint of heart, that is just part of the deal. Thanks for your post Paul and hope to see you in Austin.

jack14r
08-04-2011, 07:52 PM
Paul,I just missed yall last week,Troy got you fixed too quick.Your experience and knowledge is very helpful to all of us on this board.I have not totaled the cost of 3 years with a new coach but I think that I will now.I hope to cross paths again with you and Janice in the future.

merle&louise
08-04-2011, 08:43 PM
Paul,

I know how you feel. Karen and I were there in the beginning of this year; we had listed our coach with Ken Robertson and decided hang up the air bags! After a month or so, I changed our minds (Karen tends to go along with me in this department).

We are now in the middle of a complete renovation of the inside of the coach; every thing in the bedroom is being changed. The dinette, sofas, curtains, etc. in the front are being changed and we are very happy that we changed our minds about selling.

I will not try to change your minds, because I am sure that you and Janice have given this a good deal of thought. I will say that we will miss you two, and we hope you will make the rally in Austin.

Somebody's gonna get a good Liberty!

Jon Wehrenberg
08-05-2011, 07:21 AM
Paul,

Good luck to you and Jersey Janice. We are sure going to miss you and I wish you could somehow stay in touch with this bunch of misfits. You always brought sanity to the discussions.

johnbrowder
08-05-2011, 08:52 AM
Paul and Janice,
Janene and I certainly enjoyed getting to know you all. We wish you the best in the next stage of your lives. Someone will be getting a beautiful and well-sorted coach. Good luck, and hopefully we will see you down the road.

John Browder

phorner
08-05-2011, 09:09 PM
Thanks everyone for all the kind words.

We have thoroughly enjoyed our full-timing lifestyle, and our participation in POG has certainly enhanced our experience. We feel truly blessed to have had the opportunity to live the life of a "high end" homeless couple as we traveled these wonderful United States, especially in good health and at a relatively young age. Few folks will ever realize this experience.

We are truly thankful for the many friendships we have made, with fellow POGers in particular, and the hand of both friendship and assistance that was always so quickly offered to us.

As I mentioned, we aren't about to disappear anytime soon, as I'm sure it will take some time to figure out the logistics of selling the bus and our lot while we're still using both as home. In retrospect, a better exit plan would have sure been handy about now....

Thanks again. Safe travels everyone.

We'll probably still see ya down the road..... for a little while anyway...

Ideally, we would like to make it to POG 10, as it may well be our last rally, but we can't commit to that just yet.

Gary Carmichael
08-05-2011, 11:52 PM
Paul, Your post reminds Megan And I of our trip to Stuart, We became Liberty owners in March of 2010, We had always wanted a Prevost and were told to check out Liberty, we were driving a Newmar Essex at the time a nice coach I might add! We had looked at Featherlite at Tom Johnson, and Marathon in Coburg, We both knew when we walked in that coach it was the one 20,000 miles later we love our bus it is a member of this family! Yes I am still a green horn but we bought it to drive and that's what we do. We were lucky to get all records with the coach, and New Tires and batteries etc included in sale The original owner had spent 70,000 in upgrades in 2008. Were just happy with it. We are off to PEI on Sunday back the 28th Louisville on5-14Sept Austin 23Sept till Mid Oct Then who knows hope to see and meet you at POG10 Gary

BoaterAl
08-06-2011, 01:14 PM
Great post Paul and I agree the ownership and maintenance is not for the weak at heart. After selling the CC Affinity and watched the tail lights disappear over the hill it was not the moment I had in mind. After doing the boating thing for 30 years that was over, as the fun had disappeared. Not the same feeling with the RV. After a couple of weeks I saw a Prevost at the Flying J across the highway from our storage business. My god, that coach had a good looking paint job. Just was enough to plant the seed.
After one of our RV tenants sold his coach as some vision problems forced him to quit driving his 42 footer coach. I remember his phone call saying his RV driving days are over. It happens, just like that. Work for years to afford one of these and health says otherwise.
Our financial planner tried to talk us out of the expense of our Marathon and said all the things that are probably making good sense. Except I want one of these, we can afford it and who knows how long we can drive one.
Great bus, great rally's, great people, lots to see and do......traveling down the highway with my own bed.

Sawbonz
08-07-2011, 10:30 AM
Paul,

You posted this on the day that we picked up ours! It's not hard to see the expense, as $1000 to add a blu-ray player was on the tab, right after we decided to drop Netflix!

In any case, I agree with Al above. My in-laws worked to retire and got 3 years or so until they hit the side of a mountain and my mother-in-law died. It's still cheaper than my plane was, and I have no intentions on leaving anything for the next generation! ;)

phorner
08-07-2011, 12:22 PM
Paul,

You posted this on the day that we picked up ours! It's not hard to see the expense, as $1000 to add a blu-ray player was on the tab, right after we decided to drop Netflix!

In any case, I agree with Al above. My in-laws worked to retire and got 3 years or so until they hit the side of a mountain and my mother-in-law died. It's still cheaper than my plane was, and I have no intentions on leaving anything for the next generation! ;)

The cost, which can be substantial, is only part of the puzzle. By the time we have sold both the Liberty and our RV lot, we will have been living full-time in the coach for a decade.

We have flirted with the idea of a house a couple of times in the past, only to come to realize that we just weren't quite ready to give up this incredible lifestyle. Although not for everyone, it has been a wonderful journey.

A big part of our decision is the current real estate market, which I think will be beneficial to us as buyers for the next year or two, so we figure the time is right to start that transition to a home.

That and the fact is that I have never sold anything that I didn't get "just right" immediately before I sold it...:D

Sid Tuls
08-07-2011, 10:42 PM
Hey Paul, you got me thinking about my cost so I totalled all the repairs and maintance on my bus for the past 3.5 years

Total money spent $ 49943.85
Hit a pole with bus -$ 18360.06
------------
Money spent $ 31583.79 This includes every thing I spent on my coach new tires all around new batteries bus and house.
Total miles driven 95,365 This comes to $ .33 per mile
With the pole $ 49943.85 This comes to $ .523 per mile

The only things that I don't have in here is yearly insurance and fuel. I just thought it to interesting to find out for myself what it cost.
The big thing I see is that I put on alot of miles and yes I /we enjoy it very much having our own bed when going down the interstate.
The other thing is we don't want to scare anybody off with how much these things cost to run, but to me it's the greatest lifestyle for me and my wife. My wife doesn't read the post on here so we don't need her to know how much that little run in with the post cost :-)))

phorner
08-08-2011, 08:10 AM
Sid,

Without a doubt, the more miles the better the cost per mile will work out. Glad you're out there driving that bus! After all, that's what they were meant to do. Our Liberty is never "happier" than when she's rolling down the interstate. You can almost feel the bus just settle in at a comfortable speed and just hum right along down the highway.

My numbers weren't about scaring anybody, but this forum has provided an excellent data resource for everything "Prevost" and I thought this information might be useful for someone wanting to compare their cost of ownership. I just found it interesting to do the research. I had always kept a log book of my maintenance and repairs, just never totaled up the bottom line.

It's not all about the bottom line, however. We always accepted that the lifestyle we chose came with a certain price tag.... and to us it was worth every penny.

Jon Wehrenberg
08-08-2011, 08:20 AM
Anyone care to look at what the depreciation has been relative to the cost of fuel and maintenance? Or how about the interest on borrowed or invested money? I am not trying to be a wet blanket, but to point out that Sid is doing it right. He is using his coach and getting a lot of smiles per gallon.

Once we have made the irrational decision to buy a coach we need to just go out and enjoy it. When you get somewhere around 800,000 miles on it you might have to decide if you want to buy a new one. I'm pretty sure most of us won't put 25% of those miles on a coach.

phorner
08-08-2011, 10:18 AM
Some of the financial considerations also deal with cash flow.

For instance, depreciation is without question the lions share of the cost of bus ownership, but that "cost" isn't realized until the day you sell the bus. Kind of like a house. You haven't lost anything until the day you actually sell it. Of course, this is simplified and doesn't take into consideration the loss of use of the funds to purchase the bus, or even the cost of interest paid in the case of a financed purchase.

Maintenance costs, however, are immediate costs and can dramatically influence cash flow.

You can push the "cost" of depreciation off to some future date as it is only a figure on a balance sheet..... but you gotta keep the bus maintained with actual out of pocket expenditures now.

phorner
08-08-2011, 10:59 AM
I do agree with Jon though....

The single best thing you can do after you have decided to purchase a bus is to get out there and enjoy using it!

We have had the experience of a lifetime! There are some things that you simply can't put a price tag on. :cool:

gmcbuffalo
08-08-2011, 12:57 PM
My wife has been big in the stock market and done well, maybe one of the reason I can buy a bus, but I hear weekly how much money she could have made if I had bought the bus. It is an expensive hobby and/or lifestyle.

phorner
08-08-2011, 01:11 PM
I guess the point I wanted to make for would-be Prevost owners is that I failed to realize just how valuable a detailed, documented history of routine maintenance and desirable up-grades can be.

Whoever ends up with our Liberty will have the benefit of this documentation, which I wish I had available to me as a new owner.

For instance, I replaced my house batteries with new Lifelines (thanks Truk!) this past March partly because I had no idea how old they were. There was no documentation of any kind. Trying to be pro-active, and avoid potential problems down the road, I made the decision to not wait until they started to show signs of failure.

As it turned out, I replaced batteries that were only 4 years old. And, since it was so readily accessible during the battery replacement project, I also replaced the aux compressor. So, I probably could have spread this cost over a longer period of time.

hhoppe
08-08-2011, 04:53 PM
Paul
We will miss our twin prevost and it's ocupants. We enjoyed the brief time Shirley and I were able to spend with you and Janice. You were always and good sounding board along with Jon and others. Were indeed going to miss your input. We do not get as much use out of our bus as you do, but when we do head down the road looking for sun in winter and cool mountains and beachs durng the summer, were all smiles in our beautiful Liberty. Good luck in your sale and keep in touch. I enjoyed your sharing costs of ownership with the forum. My bus expenses run along the same amounts. God willing we'll still be on the road a few more years.
Harry & Shirley

phorner
08-08-2011, 05:37 PM
Harry,

One of the items that the new owner will get with the bus is that custom made floor platform used to remove the refrigerator. Remember when we made them? Yours is better because it has the genuine "Liberty" logo on it :D

Of course, no bus would be complete without a set of Jon's stands, so they're part of the package too...

Jon Wehrenberg
08-08-2011, 08:10 PM
I have a floor platform for the refrigerator too. I wonder why the refrigerator wasn't just put on the floor?

phorner
08-08-2011, 08:26 PM
I have a floor platform for the refrigerator too. I wonder why the refrigerator wasn't just put on the floor?

Jon,

I ask that same question myself every time I pull the refrigerator out to service the CruiseAir evaporator filter which, in my bus, is behind the fridge.

The space below the fridge is vented and allows return air for the CruiseAir in my bus....

Hey, if it was easy, then anybody could do it...:cool:

phorner
11-18-2011, 07:36 PM
Well, after 9 years and 4 months of living full time in a motorcoach, we now have a house without wheels!

Closed yesterday on a new home in TownPark at Tradition in Port Saint Lucie, Florida.

Don't let anybody tell you that the banks aren't lending money anymore...:cool:

Pete
11-18-2011, 08:03 PM
Paul & Janice, congratulations on the new home. Bet you are proud of it, and hope you will enjoy it!

JIM CHALOUPKA
11-18-2011, 08:50 PM
Great news Paul and Janice, happy to hear your fulfilling your plan.

JIM :)

merle&louise
11-18-2011, 10:53 PM
Glad for you and Janice - hope you enjoy the house.

Does it have any stainless?

If we can get down there this February, we'll give you a call.

phorner
11-19-2011, 06:19 AM
Thanks everyone!

The only stainless here is confined to the appliances....

Sawbonz
11-19-2011, 09:08 AM
Beautiful! Congratulations on your new digs. That has to be ALMOST as exciting as us closing on the bus! :)

merle&louise
11-19-2011, 09:57 AM
Paul,

You need a few Zip Dee awnings on the front!

Just kidding - nice place! We would love to come and visit for 3 or 4 months.

BoaterAl
11-19-2011, 10:38 AM
How many air doors are there ?

No roof air, must be OTR....is my guess.

phorner
04-09-2013, 05:43 PM
We have sold our beloved Liberty and the new owner will be taking possession early next month. The sale of our bus certainly comes with mixed feelings. Although we are thankful to now be be able to move forward with the next chapter of our lives, there is no question that the Prevost lifestyle will be missed.

Without POG our bus ownership would certainly have been less satisfying. We have enjoyed many good times and cultivated treasured friendships as members of POG.

Thanks for the memories and we'll see you down the road.......

Safe travels everyone!

Jamie Bradford
04-09-2013, 05:52 PM
Paul & Janice will be missed! I would like to wish you all the best and look forward to seeing you when we are visiting St. Lucie.

Jamie